2014
TCU
Illinois
Nebraska

2013
New Mexico State
Northwestern
Indiana
Michigan State
Syracuse (Texas Bowl)

2012
UNLV
Iowa
Wisconsin
Nebraska
Texas Tech (Texas Bowl)

2011
USC
Michigan
Northwestern

2010
Middle Tennessee
Illinois

2009
Northwestern
Penn State

2008
Bowling Green
Illinois
Purdue
Kansas (Insight Bowl)

2007
Florida Atlantic
Northwestern

2006
Kent State
California
Wisconsin
Ohio State
Michigan State
Texas Tech (Insight Bowl)

2005
Penn State
Iowa
Virginia (Music City Bowl)

2004
Colorado State
Michigan
Indiana
Wisconsin
Alabama (Music City Bowl)

2003
Penn State
Northwestern
Oregon (Sun Bowl)

2002
Purdue
Michigan State
Ohio State
Wisconsin

2001
Toledo
Illinois
Northwestern
Michigan
Iowa

2000
Purdue